Comparing the effectiveness of peer instruction to individual learning during a chromatography course in a blended learning environment

Julien Morice (1) , Nicolas Michinov (2) , Marine Delaval (2) , Alexandra Sideridou (3) , Vincent Ferrières (1)

1 ISCR - Institut des Sciences Chimiques de Rennes
2 LPE - Laboratoire de Psychologie Expérimentale
3 MEN : EA1279

Peer instruction has been recognized as an instructional method having a positive impact on learning compared to traditional lectures in science. This method has been widely supported by the socio-constructivist approach to learning giving a positive role to interaction between peers in the construction of knowledge. As far as we know, no study has been conducted from the socio-cognitive approach which suggests that individuals working alone perform better than those interacting with others in groups. Thus, the aim of the present study was to examine whether peer instruction improves learning when compared with an individual learning method that does not require any interaction with peers. After being randomly divided into either a peer instruction or an individual learning condition in a chromatography course, students had to answer to a series of multiple-choice questions using clickers at the beginning (pre-test) and end of (post-test) the session. Results revealed that the percentage of correct answers increased similarly from the pre- to the post-test in both conditions. Nevertheless, students perceived the peer instruction method as being more satisfying, engaging and useful than the individual learning method. The findings revealed that peer instruction provides subjective benefits, but failed to demonstrate a greater learning gain when students could interact than when they could not.

Keywords: individual learning; clickers; Peer Instruction; peer learning

Domains: Chemical Sciences

Julien Morice, Nicolas Michinov, Marine Delaval, Alexandra Sideridou, Vincent Ferrières. Comparing the effectiveness of peer instruction to individual learning during a chromatography course in a blended learning environment. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 2015, 31 (6), pp.722-733. ⟨10.1111/jcal.12116⟩. ⟨hal-01224514⟩